Transport 2000 Canada Hot Line

11 December 2009

This is the Transport 2000 Canada Hotline, issue number 1050, for 11 December 2009.

In this issue...

1 - New rail service in store for London-Stratford-Kitchener-Toronto?

"The VIAlogue of this past fall notes that, in addition to the 5 RDCs being refurbished for VIA regional and remote routes, 8 others will be rebuilt for "southwestern Ontario". This means, from what we have heard, the Toronto-Kitchener-London line where track is being improved, the egress from Toronto being upgraded by Go Transit (double track) and CTC being installed on the entire line which has been "dark" to date. We must thank the likes of Paul Langan and George Bechtel for their persistence over many years for improvements on the 'north main line'," Transport 2000 John Pearce reported on Dec. 7.

"There may be up to 5 round trips on this line, back up to the level before the Mulroney cuts of 1990. It's worth noting that the excellent and improving Boston-Portland Amtrak line (5 round trips/day) took 10 years of work by the Trainriders NorthEast advocacy group. The latest word there is an application has been made for stimulus funding to build a 30-mile extension northeast through Freeport to Brunswick," Pearce reported.

2 - Acadian bus lines abandons rural Maritimers

On Dec. 9 the Chronicle-Herald reported: "An Acadian Lines plan to revamp its bus schedules to focus on urban areas in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick will hurt rural service, says the past president of Transport 2000 Atlantic. 'All of our regional rail service disappeared 19 years ago and now the bus service seems threatened, too,' John Pearce said Tuesday. Although Acadian is proposing more express trips between the urban centres, they are cutting 'services to Cape Breton County, which has a population at least as big as all cities, except Halifax,'"

"(Pearce said) 'Also, Acadian has or is planning terminal moves to suburban or industrial locations in Saint John, Fredericton, Moncton (future) and Dartmouth. These moves fly in the face of attempts to have faster, more convenient and frequent service between major cities. Nothing is to be gained by fast express trips if you must board or disembark at obscure locations on the edge of town or in industrial parks not well served by city transit,'" Chronicle-Herald Business Reporter Tom Peters wrote.

3 - La Gaspésie se plaint du service de Via Rail

« VIA Rail s'attire une fois de plus les foudres de Dignité rurale Canada pour les réductions de services adoptées pour le train Montréal-Gaspé, désigné jusqu'à l'été comme le train Chaleur, nom qui a été enlevé par le transporteur public » Le Soleil a rapporté le 4 décembre.

« Cynthia Patterson, de Percé, coordonnatrice de Dignité rurale, critique d'ailleurs VIA Rail pour avoir débaptisé le train, une façon de miner sa mise en marché. Elle dénonce les effets du retrait du chef cuisinier à bord du Chaleur sept mois par an, et le manque de wagons pour la période des Fêtes. «VIA a remplacé le restaurant par un comptoir lunch. La qualité des aliments est médiocre. Il n'y a pas d'aliments santé. Les gens mangent à peine la moitié de ce qui est servi. En plus, la billetterie de Montréal n'avertit pas les gens qu'il n'y a plus de cuisinier à bord depuis le 17 octobre. Les passagers embarquent avec une couple de friandises. C'est long, Montréal-Gaspé [17 heures] quand on n'a rien de bon à manger», Gilles Gagné, collaboration spéciale du Soleil a écrit.

http://www.cyberpresse.ca/le-soleil/affaires/les-regions/200912/04/01-928087-la-gaspesie-se-plaint-du-service-de-via-rail.php

4 - Sault Ste. Marie-Detroit: New bus service makes the connection

Indian Trails has expanded its scheduled motor coach service in (Michigan's) Upper Peninsula, extending its route from St. Ignace to Sault Ste. Marie and adding service to Kinross and Newberry. "The route extension reintroduces daily schedule service to Sault Ste. Marie that ended back in 1993 and opens all of the Lower Peninsula and western Upper Peninsula to the U.P.'s second largest population area," Indian Trails President Gordon Mackay said in a Dec. 8 news release.

He cites the interconnect with Greyhound Canada Service and Algoma Central Rail and notes that while the expanded service is part of the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT)-sponsored U.P. service, "the extension is being operated without any increase in MDOT-subsidized taxpayer dollars."

http://www.indiantrails.com/

5 - CAA, Pollution Probe give thumbs up to draft GHG emissions regulations

"Pollution Probe's Executive Director, Bob Oliver, was quick to offer his support of the federal government's announcement of new draft regulations to limit greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from new passenger vehicles and light trucks beginning with the 2011 model year," CNW group reported on Dec. 8.

"Transportation is the source of one quarter of Canada's greenhouse gas emissions. The draft regulations announced by Environment Canada mark the first regulatory action taken by the federal government to reduce GHG emissions", says Mr. Oliver. A comprehensive backgrounder on this topic is presented in Pollution Probe's Primer on Fuel Efficiency and Emissions, launched in partnership with the Canadian Automobile Association on Nov. 6," CNW reported.

http://www.pollutionprobe.org/Publications/AutoPrimer.pdf

6 - Eliminate transit, use savings to give users green cars, taxi chits

A Dec. 8 National Post front-page story used Cato Institute figures to prove public transit is a waste of taxpayers' money. It said giving the transit subsidy directly to users for green cars and taxi fares makes economic, environmental and social justice point sense. The story warned about the power of the transit lobby.

The 4000-word Dec. 8 article did not say who funds the Cato Institute. It did not address basic holes in its proposition. If public transit was discontinued and current users switched to cars and taxis, who'd pay for the additional road capacity needed? Where would all the new cars park? How do we mitigate the environmental impacts of more cars, more roads and parking? What is the health and public safety impact of adopting complete car dependence?

For a critique of the Cato "critique", as it applies to the rail transit, see Todd Litman's Victoria Transport Policy Institute article at: http://www.vtpi.org/railcrit.pdf

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=2314363

7 - A Very Bad Day on the Toronto Subway: Steve Munro

Wednesday, December 9 was the first "snow day" for the TTC of the 2009-10 season. Although I'm now retired and should have stayed in bed listening with glee to the traffic reports, I bundled up and rode over to Bloor-Yonge Station to watch the morning rush hour with the new crowd control setup.

It was not pretty.

The crowd control actually achieved its purpose in spreading out the load on the southbound platform, but the service was a complete mess. The TTC had signal problems, service interruptions due to smoke at track level (more about this later) and a number of passenger assistance alarms (PAAs) brought on by people feeling unwell or fainting in crowded trains. A log of my observations shows the wide gaps in service with headways rarely below 4 minutes. During the two-hour period from 0800 to 1000, the TTC managed to get only 26 trains through the station, slightly fewer than they would normally operate in the peak hour.

http://stevemunro.ca/

8 - Air safety concerns: No shortcuts, please

"The House of Commons committee is reviewing Transport Canada's enforcement of regulations on air safety, including its rollout of the controversial safety management systems (SMS) protocol within the aviation industry," a Dec. 7 Halifax Chronicle Herald said.

"The unions appearing in Ottawa last week had an answer as to the effect. SMS, they said, has resulted in federal aviation inspectors so inundated with paperwork that they never leave the office to do hands-on inspections anymore. If that's the case, Transport Canada needs to re-jig its priorities. Hands-on independent inspections are vital to ensure that what the paperwork says is being done is, in fact, being done. If there's an accident due to a lack of inspections, Canadians will hold Ottawa ultimately responsible," the Chronicle Herald said.

http://thechronicleherald.ca/Editorial/1156393.html

9 - Let's get serious about rail, Historica-Dominion Institute says

"Our rail service is abysmal, one of the great failures of public policy. We are at least a generation behind Europe and Asia. The costs are mounting. A country that built a mythical transcontinental railway in the 19th century has largely abandoned passenger service today," Andrew Cohen wrote in an Ottawa Citizen op-ed on Dec. 8.

"(This) is a picture of inter-city rail service in the most densely populated corridor in Canada: delays, infrequent service, tired carriages, few amenities. It sends commuters between Montreal, Ottawa and Toronto into the air. There is a reason that Porter Airlines, which flies to and from Toronto Island some 30 times a day, is surging; you can leave your home in Ottawa and arrive in downtown Toronto within two and a half hours," the Citizen op-ed said.

"Let's get real. The industrialized world is serious about rail, but Canada is not. When we decided to bail out automakers with $10 billion, we missed an opportunity to retool automotive plants and retrain workers, constituting a massive investment in public transit. High-speed rail itself may not be the answer but better, faster service is. This is the land that bound itself in a ribbon of steel and called itself a country. Can we find the will to do the same today?," Andrew Cohen, president of The Historica-Dominion Institute wrote in the Citizen.

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/todays-paper/serious+about+rail/2315216/story.html


Thank you for calling the Transport 2000 Canada Hotline. For additional information, please contact our web site at:

www.transport2000.ca.